Recent

Your Slant Is Showing

Same incident. Two newspapers. Two sets of headlines. You guess their editorial policy.

Share on

Aah, our newspapers. They never disappoint. It’s always nice to slip in editorial leanings as subtly as possible. Of course, sometimes they aren’t that subtle. If you got Delhi editions of The Indian Express and The Times Of India today, and went just by their headlines and front-page images, you’d be a little perplexed about what took place at India Gate on Sunday. Were hooligans at the gate, the literal gate that is? Were the people taking over? Where were the police?

Take The Indian Express. There’s a headline – “Delhi protests take violent turn, 150 injured, policemen critical”. And an image of an over-turned car and a young boy lobbing what looks like a stone. There’s not a cop to be seen in the vicinity. Maybe the mob turned so violent, that the cops fled the spot? And then there’s the sub-head. Which has a charm and innovativeness all its own.

GANGRAPE: Ramdev, VK Singh join protest, police say hooligans in mob

Clever placement of the comma after protest. Ramdev and VK Singh might be a lot of things, but inferring they’re hooligans?

Newspaper-Headlines-1

Then there’s the editorially-challenged The Times Of India. Their headline was – “The People Are At The Gate”. Accompanied by an image of the marauding hordes which was made up of three (3) “people” – one old cowering woman, a young girl and a crouching young boy. And there’s a cop just about to strike them with a lathi. And another bunch of cops surrounding them. Let’s not miss the skewed statistics as well. TOI is the only one who said that 65 protesters have been hurt, and 78 cops injured. All other newspapers have the figure of injured protesters at 143, and one cop in the injured lot. But let’s not quibble, what’s a fact here or there?

Newspaper-Headlines-2

And if our newspapers aren’t going to play around with headlines and images, who is? Maybe they’ve just learnt from the pioneers in the West.

Remember when TIME magazine wrote about the Soviet Union shooting down a Korean passenger plane. As it very subtly stated on a magazine cover dedicated to the incident “Shooting to Kill – The Soviets Destroy An Airliner”. Not to miss the picture accompanying it. They might as well have thrown in some Korean bodies flying through the air.  http://www.time.com/time/covers/0,16641,19830912,00.html

Newspaper headlines 3

What’s wrong with that you ask? Well, you just have to compare it to the magazine’s coverage when an American naval warship patrolling the Persian Gulf shot down an Iranian passenger jet after supposedly mistaking it for a fighter plane. TIME didn’t think it necessary to carry an issue dedicated to the downing of the passenger plane, then. Or to call out their graphic designer to draw a horrific picture of an Iranian Jet being blown to bits.

Instead, they had a little sub-head on the top-left corner of the cover which stated – “Iran’s Jetliner. A Clash Turns To Tragedy”. If you were slightly near-sighted, you’d have missed it.

News-Headlines-4

Different strokes for different folks? For TIME, it all depended on who was at fault. The US or the Soviet Union. And for our home-grown boys, the headlines depend on whether the UPA is at fault or not. Objective reporting and headlines be damned.

Contact Rajyasree

 

 

Comment Policy: We encourage discussion and debate in our comments, among viewers and writers. However comments that are abusive or personal in nature, will be deleted.

1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (22 votes, average: 4.95 out of 5)
Loading ... Loading ...

 

More from Rajyasree Sen


  • MKN

    Good work Rajyasree Sen.
    – from a victim whose mind has been ‘raped’ for years by these biased media houses.

  • http://twitter.com/de_blacksmith Gurmeetsingh Mehtab

    Well well written. Ive always felt that TOI is slanted to the nth degree. Your article confirmed my doubt. It appears as if the Press only wants to create more news, and more online hits/comments. So unless they provoke, they wont get the desired reactions.

  • Anil

    Have been an Indian Express reader for over a decade,however given the very noticeable pro UPA/ Congress slant, it is getting very difficult to reconcile what appears in the newspaper currently. The Indian Express is not objective at all. Very diappointing indeed.

  • Troll007

    Atleast TOI is with the people (or probably moving closer to the BJP sensing the imminent change in power) but Shekhar Gupta continues to drag IE through the muck that he & others at IE have created thanks to their cozy relationship with UPA over the years with the fake army coup story, his name appearing in Wikileaks & CWG contracts etc. All that’s left to say is may Ramnath Goenka’s soul rest in peace.

  • ruchi

    good piece!

  • Suresh P

    Good one! I think there should be a newspaper which compiles news from different sources. An offline one!

Menu
Read previous post:
Journalist Nanao Shot dead
Nanao: Death Of A Colleague

An under-reported story. An under-reported killing. A journalist is shot dead in Imphal.

Close