Report
DK Shivakumar’s ‘lasting legacy’: A Bengaluru tunnel project mired in questions
In the last three years, if there is one infrastructure project that has taken over the public imagination in Bengaluru, it is the twin tunnel road project. Pitched by Deputy Chief Minister-turned-Chief Minister DK Shivakumar as his “lasting legacy” for the city, the plan envisions two tunnel roads: one running from Hebbal in the north to Silk Board in the south, and another from KR Puram in the east to Nayandahalli in the west. It has been sold as the answer to a city choking on its own traffic and wrapped, like so much else, in the shiny packaging of ‘Brand Bengaluru’.
But the closer the project gets to reality, the more it has come to resemble a lightning rod. The government has already been hemmed in by a High Court order stating that any contract awarded for the tunnel project would remain subject to the outcome of the public interest litigations challenging it, with no equities to be created in the meantime.
That order effectively froze its plans just as it had zeroed in on Adani Enterprises as the lowest bidder for the North-South tunnel, a bid that came in at a staggering Rs 4,600 crore above the government’s own estimate of Rs 17,698 crore. Then, in the face of massive public protests, the government was forced to withdraw an amendment that would have opened up lands inside public parks for infrastructure, a second setback for what is often called Shivakumar’s “pet” project.
What makes these setbacks telling is the breakneck pace at which the government has tried to push the project through. The Detailed Project Report (DPR), the document on which a project of this magnitude is supposed to rest, was a rush job completed in just three months by Rodic Consultants, against an industry norm of nine to 12 months. It was a sloppy one too. The draft referred to locations in Maharashtra instead of Karnataka, earning the consultants a Rs 5 lakh fine from Bruhat Bengaluru Mahanagara Palike (BBMP), followed by another Rs 10 lakh for more errors.
Petitioners before the High Court say the DPR had no site-specific studies, no initial borehole drilling or on-site geotechnical testing, and a traffic model that left out two-wheelers and autos, which make up nearly 70% of Bengaluru’s vehicles. The government, it turns out, had called for bids to prepare the DPR before the feasibility report it was meant to build on had even been submitted.
IISc reports have warned that tunnel roads could merely shift traffic bottlenecks to new choke points rather than resolve the city’s congestion. The tunnels are meant only for cars, at a probable steep toll of about Rs 640 for a round trip between Hebbal and Silk Board, which means a project that claims to help the city “move forward seamlessly” would serve only a sliver of its people, unless the government subsidises it. And all this while the Metro’s Red Line crawls, the Suburban Rail project languishes at under 20 per cent progress, and BMTC struggles to meet the city’s basic bus requirements.
For a city choking on traffic, the question is what the government hopes to achieve with a project that would cater to a minuscule population of car owners, even as scientific assessments question its ability to ease congestion.
This story examines the legal challenges and financial and environmental implications of the tunnel project. Drawing on court petitions, government documents, the Detailed Project Report (DPR), and interviews with experts, activists and government representatives, it looks into the questions surrounding the project and the government's defence.
A chokehold called ‘Brand Bengaluru’
Talks about setting in motion plans for construction of two tunnel roads – North-South and East-West corridors – began as early as July 2023, a mere two months after Congress came to power in Karnataka. And the then Bengaluru Development Minister, DK Shivakumar set off a slew of projects, long tunnels, short tunnels, elevated expressways, flyovers, double-deckers, et al., to ease traffic congestion and decrease commute times—all in the name of ‘Brand Bengaluru’.
This blunt force approach has only succeeded in aggravating a city fatigued with constant construction, badly maintained roads, poor traffic management and the average driver’s penchant for lawlessness on the road. Commute times have been steadily increasing, and vehicular speeds have only been decreasing. Potholes and poor asphalting dot every road all over the city. Traffic management is often erratic, with police focus on tech-driven solutions not making any headway with the ever-increasing vehicular density.
The biggest casualty in the government's singular pursuit of the tunnel project has been the neglect of public transport projects. For instance, the North-South corridor of the tunnel project from Hebbal to Silk Board practically runs parallel to the Metro Red line or Phase 3A – a 37.8 km line from Hebbal in the north to Sarjapur in the southeast – which was announced by the BJP government in the 2022-23 budget.
That metro proposal has moved at a snail’s pace, while the government was practically ready to approve the more expensive tunnel project, catering to a minuscule population of private car drivers.
Right off the bat, the Union and state governments were in a standoff over the design for the line. The state government wanted a double-decker, a road and the elevated metro segment (23.52 kms), something the Union government objected to, as it would reduce the point of having a metro and increase costs. After much back and forth and consultations, the government scaled back on the double-decker and even removed a station at Veterinary Science College and brought down the costs from Rs 28,405 crore to Rs 25,999 crore for the 37.8 km stretch. This line has still not received Union government approval.
As recently as November 11, Bengaluru Development Minister Krishna Byre Gowda said that there was a demand for a double-decker on that corridor, and the state government would seek the PM’s intervention for approval of the line.
Even if that happens, the earliest the work would commence would be the end of next year, according to the state government’s estimate.
If the Adani bid moves forward, then we are looking at a tunnel road, whose cost will be Rs 1,329.37 crore per km, while it will be Rs 687.80 crore for the metro red line.
The most unfortunate of public transport projects has been the Bengaluru Suburban Rail Project. This is a 148-kilometre commuter rail network, covering four routes, and it is expected to carry 20 lakh passengers daily. The project took decades to get approval from the Union government. It was constantly set aside to give priority to Metro; the Indian Railways were reluctant to take it on since they treated this as a loss-making proposition, and there was general apathy, as no department took the lead in pushing it.
It finally got off the ground with the Union government’s approval in 2020. As of 2026, it is crawling at this stage, with only 19.95% of overall progress in physical terms and 20.66% in financial terms. The original deadline of October 2026 has been pushed to 2030.
Satya Arikutharam, an independent urban mobility expert, is one of the people who have relentlessly excoriated the tunnel road project. Speaking to TNM, he said, “All public transport projects have been stalled and put on the back burner because of the distractions from car-centric transport in the last three years. The state government started quite well by promoting the Shakti scheme, incentivising public transport.
“But after that, it starved BMTC of new buses, and it starved BMRCL of the shadow cash support, which meant that we are paying the highest metro fare in the entire country. Then they introduced these two projects, the tunnel projects and all these flyover projects and double-decker concepts, which meant that both the red line and the orange line got mired in confusion and controversies. Essentially, the last three years have been annus horribiles for public transport.” The Shakti scheme, introduced by the Karnataka government in 2023, offers free bus travel to women.
The Bangalore Metropolitan Transport Corporation (BMTC) has been slowly expanding the number of buses, but the increase has not been tremendous, as it has been scrapping old buses and also catering to expanding boundary lines of the city and infrastructure limitations. The city has around 7,000 buses, whereas the recommended number of buses for the present population is around 14,000 to 15,000 buses.
Despite the critical need of the hour being the focus on improving public transport and urban migration, Shivakumar has been pushing his VIP lane project like a juggernaut, rolling over repeated objections from virtually everyone—the general public, mobility experts, environmentalists, scientists, and opposition parties’ legislators.
As Bengaluru Development Minister, Krishna Byre Gowda has also advocated for the tunnel project time and again.
“Since road widening at a mass scale is not possible, we have to think about going under or above,” he said at an event organised by The Hindu. “I too wish we didn’t have to build tunnels and elevated roads. But how do you cater to a city of 1.5 crore population with 1.5 crore vehicles?” he asked.
“We are not saying that a tunnel is the only solution to the traffic congestion in Bengaluru – it is part of the solution. If people think the tunnel road is the only solution that the government has for the traffic problem, then it is a jaundiced view”, he argued.
The government’s line of reasoning for a tunnel road has rested on a single myopic premise.
Widening of existing roads is difficult due to scarcity of land and problems in land acquisition. In this backdrop, the State Government has decided to resolve traffic congestion in the city by constructing underground tunnels. On a pilot basis, a tunnel will be constructed this year at Hebbal junction, where there is high traffic congestion.Government of Karnataka budget 2024-25
In the process, the pre-feasibility report and the Detailed Project Report were shoddily prepared and hastily accepted; the tender for one part of the project finally zoomed in on Adani Enterprises, which turned out to be the lowest bidder, even after quoting Rs 4,600 crore more than the government's estimated cost. Further, amendments were brought about swiftly to enable sweeping changes, notably the amendment to the Karnataka Government Parks (Preservation) Act, 1975, allowing the government to utilise 5% of a park for public utility and infrastructure projects. This was scrapped after relentless public protests.
The Karnataka government passed the Bengaluru Metropolitan Land Transport Authority (BMLTA) Act in 2022. This was an agency formed to bring multiple overlapping civic and transit agencies under one unified umbrella for integrated planning, regulation, coordination and approval of urban mobility projects in the Bengaluru Metropolitan area.
The government was supposed to get BMLTA's approval for major projects. But the government found a way to bypass this. It amended the law and introduced Rule 24 to say that all projects initiated between 2022 and the notification of the BMLTA Rules in 2026 would be treated as if they had already received BMLTA's approval.
This was after an earlier attempt to create an ‘exemption’ landed in court. Rule 24 gave retrospective approval to many big-ticket projects, such as tunnel projects, numerous flyovers, and elevated corridors, roughly expected to cost around Rs 1.5 lakh crore.
Dattatreya Devare, Trustee of Bangalore Environment Trust and one of the petitioners against the earlier ‘exemption’ attempt, obtained details on how many people objected to Rule 24. “After great difficulty, they provided me with information that 209 people had submitted objections. Every single person out of those 209 had objected to Rule 24. Okay. But still, they retained it. That means they don't care for public comments or opinions. Inviting objections is just a ritual and a formality. They do whatever they want later, so this is the state of affairs,” he told TNM.
Probably the most egregious violation of public trust was circumventing the Environmental Impact Assessment, using a flimsy exemption and subverting the intent of a central law. A basic assessment by the BBMP says 222 trees will get the axe on the present alignment on the North-South corridor.
It is an understated number we are hard-pressed to believe, since the Bangalore Development Authority (BDA) had applied for cutting 1,228 trees for just the 2.3 km Hebbal short tunnel. The construction of the short tunnel is proceeding at a brisk pace, despite ecological concerns, widespread protests and legal restrictions on the felling of trees.
As Rule 24 is now being challenged, the government has now circumvented that and brought in an amendment to Section 19(5) for the same time period. “All the decisions taken, plans prepared, operations undertaken and proceedings pending in relation to such projects shall be deemed to have been taken, prepared, undertaken or instituted, as the case may be, under this Act,” the amendment says.
Not 5%, not 1%, not one inch
Not all battles were being fought in the courts.
On an early Sunday morning in August, a small group of people had gathered around the famed Lalbagh rock in Lalbagh Botanical Gardens. That particular rock is a popular gathering place for walkers and sightseeing enthusiasts. But on that morning, like the previous two Sundays, the group of people had clustered to protest against the recent amendment made to the Karnataka Government Parks (Preservation) Act, 1975. The amendment would allow the government to utilise 5% of any public parks and gardens for public infrastructure and utility projects, notably the controversial North-South tunnel road project that would consume six acres of Lalbagh Gardens.
As it was the third successive Sunday of protests, the police also had a considerable presence, so much so that one of the policemen mocked a protester, saying there were more of them than the protesters and it was going nowhere. The policeman’s statement proved to be hopelessly premature.
The next Sunday, on August 30, thousands gathered at ‘Lalbagh rock’, a hoary complex of metamorphic rocks, estimated to be older than three billion years. It was a crowd that was discussing ‘peninsular gneiss’ and singing the old popular Rajkumar song, Gandhadagudi, in the same breath. And they did not want to cede an inch of Lalbagh to commercial interests.
It was led by a 90-year-old man, AN Yellappa Reddy, a retired Indian Forest Service officer and an environmentalist, who bluntly questioned who, how and why the government came up with taking over 5% of public parks. Not even the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) leaders, who had been protesting for a while, could overshadow his zeal in holding the government accountable.
Of the many letters he shot off questioning the wisdom of trying to occupy park lands, one was to Chief Minister DK Shivakumar’s daughter, Aishwarya, in which he chided, “Bengaluru is becoming denser every year. Buildings can be rebuilt. Roads can be realigned. Engineering designs can change. But a mature ecological system which has taken generations to develop cannot simply be recreated somewhere else by planting a few saplings.”
Two days after the protest, Shivakumar announced they would review the amendment, and another two days later, Deputy Chief Minister G Parameshwara, briefing reporters after a Cabinet meeting, announced they were withdrawing the amendment in the face of massive public protests.
By this time, the government had already been constrained by a High Court order stating that any contract awarded for the proposed twin tunnel project would remain subject to the outcome of the two public interest litigation cases challenging the project. It also observed that no equities should be created during the pendency of the proceedings.
It was an impasse for the government, which had already zeroed in on billionaire Gautam Adani’s company. The court order put a stop to it effectively.
And thus, the Congress-run Karnataka government faced its second setback for the ambitious twin tunnel road project, often referred to as the ‘pet’ project of DK Shivakumar. He has often said that the twin tunnel road project would be his “lasting legacy” for Bengaluru. According to him, the tunnel project would “ensure the city moves forward seamlessly”, a bold but questionable claim.
‘Lasting legacy’ for whom?
The twin tunnel roads project is a proposal for two underground tunnel roads to be constructed from Bengaluru North to South and another from East to West. These tunnels will be double-decker roads. From North to South, the tunnel will connect Hebbal to Silk Board, with a distance of 16.681 km. The tunnel will have three lanes on both sides.
The East-West corridor, with a distance of 28.19 km, will run from KR Puram to Nayandahalli Circle. The upper deck (KR Puram to Nayandahalli Circle) will be two lanes, and the lower deck (Nayandahalli Circle to KR Puram) will be three lanes.
The projects are being implemented by Bengaluru Smart Infrastructure Limited (B-SMILE), a Special Purpose Vehicle for executing infrastructure projects.
The government first floated a tender bid for the North-South corridor divided into two packages. The first package is from Hebbal (Esteem Mall junction) to Seshadri Road, Freedom Park, and the second package is from Seshadri Road to Silk Board. The two corridors intersect at Lalbagh Botanical Gardens, a scenario that alarmed the citizenry enough that they came out in large numbers to protest—something that had not been seen since the Steel Flyover Beda (We don’t want a steel flyover) protests in 2016. That project was officially scrapped in 2017.
The objections to this project were numerous. In January 2025, a group of citizens under the Alliance For Sustainable Urban Priorities wrote to then Chief Minister Siddaramaiah seeking a meeting to convey their concerns about the slew of infrastructure projects that had been announced. These comprised the twin tunnel road project, a 250-metre-high sky deck, expressways, flyovers, double-decker roads, etc. The twin tunnel project alone was set to cost around Rs 35,000 crore.
“When several fundamental rights and basic needs of Karnataka's citizens have not been met due to a shortage of funds, spending on the luxury needs of a few raises questions. Tunnel roads will benefit only the 23 lakh private car owners of Bengaluru, who are a mere 2.8 % of the approximately 7 crore population of the State. To spend Rs 16,500 crore (earlier estimate for the North-South tunnel road) or Rs 50,000 crore to satisfy their desire to drive in their own private vehicles is questionable when the entire backward Kalyana Karnataka is hardly given Rs 3,000 crore per year, and even that is not spent fully every year,” they wrote.
Two public interest litigations were filed challenging the decision to construct the tunnel road. The first one was filed by A Ravindra, a retired IAS officer; Vinod Vyasulu, a public policy expert; and NS Mukunda, a civic activist and founding president of the Citizen Action Forum. The second one was filed by Prakash Belawadi, a well-known actor, director, and activist.
Ravindra’s petition called the project a “wasteful deployment of scarce public resources and an unjustifiable financial burden on ordinary road users.” The petitioners argued that the state was “spending scarce public resources for a discriminatory, car-centric facility that privileges an affluent minority while exposing the city to long-term fiscal and ecological harm.”
By restricting the tunnel road access to private cars and taxis, they argued it created an arbitrary classification among urban commuters. They contended that it did not explain how the measure would reduce congestion, improve safety, or recover costs. “Excluding two-wheelers and auto-rickshaws, which account for a substantial share of peak-hour trips, cannot reduce congestion on the network. Further, removing buses from using this tunnel road is arbitrary and defeats the stated objective of decongestion,” they contended.
They also argued that even for car users, the tolls were a recurring financial burden as they had already paid motor vehicle tax, road tax and fuel levies.
“A public infrastructure that is conceived and executed primarily for the benefit of a single, affluent mode, while excluding mass and para-transit and low-income modes, fails the test of reasonableness, undermines the public purpose of urban mobility planning, and violates the principles of equality and proportionality under Article 14,” the petitioners said.
The second petition filed by Prakash Belawadi was no less charitable. “The North-South Tunnel Road Project is being illegally pursued by Karnataka through B-SMILE at an estimated cost of 19,000 crore without any application of mind, without statutory approvals and in violation of the constitutional mandate,” the petition firmly stated. It then went on to give an exhaustive list of violations and irregularities they alleged the government had indulged in so this project could go through without checking boxes among the numerous laws. The petitions have been bunched, and the matter is being heard after passing that any contracts or tenders awarded for the project remain strictly subject to the final outcome of the PILs.
Colourable exercise of power
Among the contentious issues is how the state government conveniently claimed there wasn’t a need for environmental clearance. On November 26, 2024, the State Level Environment Impact Assessment Authority (SEIAA), Karnataka, issued an official letter to the BBMP formally declaring that the 18 km tunnel route does not attract the requirement of prior Environmental Clearance (EC) under the EIA Notification, 2006.
The official rationale rests on statutory provisions in the 2006 notification from the Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change (MoEFCC). The 2006 environmental rules do not specifically list standalone urban road tunnels as projects that need clearance. The rules do cover highways, but they exempt certain highway expansion projects of up to 100 km from environmental clearance, provided they meet specific conditions relating to land acquisition. Using this, the government claimed an exemption.
Further, in their statement of reasons to the Court, the state said the “project is outside any legally protected, ecologically sensitive, or critical habitat areas”. Most adverse impacts, it said, are confined to the construction stage, are site-specific and limited to the right of way (RoW), and dismissed the impacts, giving a vague assurance that they were “easily mitigated through good engineering and environmentally acceptable practices”.
The government also ignored notices from the Union government issued in the wake of the 2023 Silkyara tunnel road construction collapse, which said that tunnels longer than 1.5 km must get prior expert advice on geological, geotechnical and geophysical studies; the tunnel alignment report and design; electro-mechanical works; cost estimates; and instrumentation and safety measures during construction and operation.
The roadblocks for this project were cleared with an alacrity not typically associated with government work. A Turkish company, Altinok Consulting Engineering Private Limited, a joint venture with Lion Engineering Consultants Private Limited, was selected in December 2023 to provide a feasibility report to “decongest traffic and to prepare a comprehensive traffic management plan for the proposal of a vehicular tunnel/Grade separator/Road widening in selected corridors”.
Altinok Consulting, which was subsequently issued debarment notices twice – in 2025 and 2026 by the National Highways Authority of India – had not even submitted its report when the government called for bids to prepare a Detailed Project Report (DPR).
Altinok was debarred due to persistent contractual breaches, including failing to deploy required key personnel on site, recommending payments without proper field scrutiny, failing to detect design and quality defects, procedural failures and persistently failing to comply with official directives despite multiple notices. Another notice was issued because Altinok failed to declare it was a foreign entity, but this was withdrawn after a court ruled in Altinok’s favour.
When the feasibility report was finally released by Altinok in December 2024, it drew criticism, as it had borrowed heavily from a 2022 report prepared by BMRCL.
In a long post, Satya Arikutharam criticised the report, saying, “After three weeks of examining the BBMP's Final Feasibility Report, here is my verdict. It’s not worth the paper it’s printed on, let alone the Rs 4.5 crore fees.” The actual fee paid was Rs 5.54 crore. He criticised the report for generously borrowing from the DPR, which was actually commissioned later, and the transport model it recommended was borrowed from the Comprehensive Mobility Plan 2020.
The DPR, meanwhile, was prepared by Rodic Consultants, a rush job they completed in just three months and were paid Rs 9.45 crore for.
The DPR prepared by Rodic Consultants is vitiated by gross negligence and reckless disregard for professional and statutory obligations, the petition filed by A Ravindra alleged. “The DPR, for a project of this magnitude and environmental sensitivity, was purportedly completed within an unreasonably truncated period of merely three months, contrary to established industry practice requiring a minimum of 9 to 12 months of comprehensive surveys, studies and technical evaluations. This undue haste has manifestly compromised the integrity and reliability of the DPR.”
The petitioners pointed out that Rodic Consultants were penalised with a fine of Rs 5 lakh for a “fundamental and inexcusable error” wherein the draft DPR referred to locations in Maharashtra instead of Karnataka.
Subsequently, they were fined Rs 10 lakh for missing deadlines. “Such a glaring blunder in a statutory planning document for a flagship project demonstrates a complete abdication of professional due diligence, an absence of quality control, and an alarming level of carelessness that renders the DPR legally unreliable and unfit to be the basis for any public infrastructure decision-making,” the petition said.
Crucially, the DPR omitted any site-specific studies. As the complaints raged, “no borehole drilling or in-situ geotechnical testing was undertaken; hydrological and flood-risk modelling was not carried out despite the alignment cutting across stormwater drains; and flawed traffic modelling (it used false data) and projections excluded two-wheelers and auto-rickshaws, which constitute nearly 70% of Bengaluru’s vehicular population.”
Even on its own assumptions, the DPR admitted that several key junctions would remain at the worst congestion levels even after the construction of the tunnel roads.
These defects render the DPR legally unreliable and demonstrate that the impugned Project has been advanced without a scientific basis, in violation of statutory environmental safeguards.
Satya also pointed out that initially, rather than conducting fresh primary geotechnical probing along the proposed 18.5 km subterranean corridor, the DPR consultants relied heavily on secondary historical data borrowed from the parallel Namma Metro Red Line DPR, which had previously drilled 69 boreholes along its alignment. Operating under the assumption that the nearby geology would be identical, the project planners effectively deferred primary site investigations to the future concessionaire.
“Even their so-called expert committee also pointed out this was lacking. And then BBMP belatedly drilled some 18 boreholes, which was inadequate for that particular line.”
That work was done following intense criticism from technical experts and public interest petitioners, who highlighted that excavating twin-tube highway tunnels using heavy Tunnel Boring Machines (TBM) and the New Austrian Tunnelling Method (NATM) through granitic formations and fractured rock aquifers requires dense, corridor-specific sampling. This belated addition was considered still vastly inadequate for an 18.5 km subterranean highway project.
Contrary to the DPR’s assertion that there is “no need for extensive land acquisition”, the twin-tunnel construction still requires significant land acquisition, both on the surface and below ground. Large parcels of land are needed to build entry and exit ramps, widen connecting roads and set up staging yards for launching Tunnel Boring Machines (TBMs).
Land must also be acquired at regular intervals for ventilation towers, emergency exits, electrical substations and the relocation of underground utilities. In addition, authorities need to secure subsurface rights beneath private properties to create safety buffers and prevent future deep-foundation work or borewell drilling from damaging the tunnels.
What those pesky scientific reports say
At a small gathering of scientists, environmental activists and lawyers in early September, Yellappa Reddy thundered, “With no carbon sink to absorb carbon dioxide and help mitigate pollution, is there any alternative to trees? How many trees are already being sacrificed in Bengaluru, and how many more will be destroyed in the name of development — is this sustainable development? How dare you destroy millions of treesHe was asking for a good reason.
The BBMP said it would plant 2,200 trees for the 222 trees they would have to chop. With abysmal rates of survival for saplings and even those transplanted, there was no way for the trees to survive. Moreover, the group argued, if you can shift the trees elsewhere, you can shift the development elsewhere too.
Last year, Professor Ashish Verma, Convenor, Transportation Systems Engineering Cell, and his team at Sustainable Transportation Lab, IISc, submitted a report on potential impacts of the tunnel road project to the Governor dispelling all the putative benefits the state was touting from the tunnel roads. “The tunnel road does not provide a comprehensive solution for city-wide traffic issues. As a result, it does not address broader congestion challenges faced by Bengaluru,” the report said.
On the contrary, what it would do is shift the traffic elsewhere and create other chokepoints. There would not be too many takers for the tolled road either.
“Eventually, the traffic estimate also shows that it will not attract much traffic due to the toll, and the condition of vehicle flow will remain the same. So, it will be super-rich people or VIPs, or even bureaucrats who will keep using it. It is totally outrageous how they are coming up with ideas to somehow make this VIP corridor possible, disregarding logic or scientific data in place,” Ashish Verma told TNM.
The study analysed travel demand and traffic volumes under three scenarios/cases: Tolled Tunnel Road; Toll-Free Tunnel Road and Using Potential Traffic Shift. It also analysed seven future-year scenarios, spanning 2030 to 2060 at 5-year intervals.
Findings: Total traffic flow, measured in vehicles, is consistently very low across all years from 2030 to 2060. By 2060, the tunnel’s volume-to-capacity (V/C) ratio is projected to be just 0.1245, indicating that traffic would use only about 12.45% of its capacity under the toll scenario. This suggests that the tunnel would remain significantly underutilised, with substantial spare capacity, potentially because the toll discourages some motorists from using it.
Even without a toll, it would be significantly underutilised, with approximately 19.56% of the road’s capacity being used by 2060.
In the third scenario, where potentially more vehicles would use the tunnel, a traffic volume of approximately 55% of the road's capacity would be used in 2045 and 2060.
In other words, the road is using just over half of its estimated capacity, leaving about 45% unused under the modelled conditions.
The introduction of the tunnel project is projected to significantly increase harmful emissions. The key performance indicators suggest it is an expensive, inequitable, and environmentally damaging proposal that falls short of its primary goal.IISc report on Potential Impacts of Bengaluru Tunnel Road Project
Prof. Verma says that the government’s priority should be to expand the mass rapid transit system (suburban rail and metro), which is 450-plus kilometres as per their respective master plans. “A dense spiderweb-like network in our city where you should be able to travel anywhere to any part of the city using a combination of radial and circular lines with easy access to a metro station or a suburban station nearby. Metro stations should be within walking distance.
Otherwise, people are struggling with first-mile-last-mile connectivity. All these things are plaguing the city due to the misguided and misplaced priority of the government on building these grade separators, tunnel roads, or elevated corridors. We keep making it more difficult for public transport to be accessible and expand quickly. For this long tunnel, they've already dropped one important station near Veterinary College on Line 3.”
Earlier this year, following safety concerns raised by BJP MP Tejasvi Surya regarding potential damage to Lalbagh Botanical Garden's 3-billion-year-old rock monument, an expert panel from the Geological Survey of India (GSI) conducted an on-site technical inspection. Their evaluation of the project DPR was submitted directly to the High Court of Karnataka.
The report identified several issues, including that the tunnel’s depth was insufficient, raising the risk of surface cracking or ground sinking. Also of concern was the 40-metre pit that will be dug inside Lalbagh (TBM Shaft 4). The report said that digging this deep shaft into hard granite required heavy drilling and blasting. They warned that these intense vibrations could crack or permanently damage the ancient rock monument and threaten the structural stability of the nearby Kempegowda watchtower.
Then there was the government-appointed expert committee formed to review the DPR prepared by Rodic Consultants Pvt. Ltd for the proposed North–South vehicular tunnel project. It flagged several concerns over geological investigations, potential conflicts with mass transit infrastructure, project costs and the independence of the technical review.
The committee was chaired by Siddanagouda Hegaraddi, Executive Director (Civil) at Bangalore Metro Rail Corporation Limited (BMRCL). The key findings of the review included:
Incomplete geological investigations: The committee found that the submitted geotechnical report relied mainly on geophysical studies and data from just four boreholes, with further investigations still underway. It also flagged the absence of electrical resistivity tomography (ERT) tests to assess groundwater and aquifers.
Metro alignment and Lalbagh shaft: The proposed tunnel ran almost parallel to a planned Metro line, raising questions about potential overlap in purpose. The committee said the lack of peak-hour traffic data and modal-share analysis made this difficult to assess. It also recommended reconsidering a proposed shaft inside Lalbagh Botanical Garden.
Traffic projections and lane design: The DPR used 2041 as its traffic forecast horizon, which the committee said fell short of the 25-year period prescribed under IRC guidelines. It also flagged a mismatch between projected traffic requirements and the proposed six-lane tunnel and called for better analysis of the shift to public transport.
Drainage and flood management: The committee found that detailed drainage design calculations were missing and questioned the proposed diversion of a drain downstream of Hebbal Tank’s waste weir. It sought hydraulic calculations based on a 100-year flood return period or the applicable standard project flood.
Missing assessments and documentation: The DPR lacked several key details, including land acquisition plans, utility mapping and relocation, tree enumeration, environmental and social impact assessments, rehabilitation measures, technical specifications and a comprehensive disaster management and security plan.
Incomplete cost estimates: The proposed tunnel-boring machine (TBM) cost was based on a quotation from a single vendor, rather than the three quotations generally required under Karnataka Public Works Department norms for non-schedule items. The committee also identified missing costs related to excavated material disposal, secondary grouting, cutter-disc consumption and 25 years of operation and maintenance.
Construction schedule and methods: The committee questioned whether the proposed timeline was realistic given land acquisition, utility shifting, tree removal, traffic diversions, restricted working hours and Bengaluru’s geology. It recommended a detailed construction schedule and method statements for tunnel and shaft excavation.
Ventilation and electrical systems: It called for a cost comparison of transverse and longitudinal ventilation systems. It also flagged the proposed placement of electrical substations inside the TBM tunnel as potentially risky and expensive, recommending that locations outside the tunnel be explored.
Tunnelling risks and project readiness: Citing hard and abrasive rock encountered during Metro construction, the committee called for detailed geological studies, careful TBM selection and assessment of vibration impacts on nearby structures. It also recommended revising the tunnelling schedule, ensuring at least 90% of the work site was free of encumbrances before contract award, and setting up a single-window monitoring committee.
One man, every party
The final round of the bidding process for the North-South tunnel road from Hebbal to Silk Board (in two packages), estimated to cost Rs 17,698 crore, left four bidders: Dilip Buildcon, Rail Vikas Nigam Limited (RVNL), Vishwa Samudra, and Adani Enterprises.
Of these, Dilip Buildcon and Rail Vikas Nigam Limited (RVNL) had extensive experience in road and tunnel rail projects, but they were eliminated.
Dilip Buildcon was disqualified, as it violated a clause which barred bidders with any history of the collapse of a bridge, flyover, or tunnel. RVNL was eliminated after its joint venture partner failed to meet the technical criteria. It was Adani Enterprises which emerged as the lowest bidder. But the Adani group quoted Rs 22,267 crore for the project. Considering that this was the fourth time the government called for tenders for this project, they were unlikely to call for bids again. With Adani jacking up the price, the government’s share of 40% for the project also went up.
A 40% Viability Gap Funding (VGF) commitment meant the government expected to pay a fixed grant of approximately Rs 7,079 crore to Rs 7,200 crore, with the winning private concessionaire financing the remaining 60%. Because a 40% VGF on Adani's bid would inflate the government's direct cash burden by nearly Rs 1,800 crore, the state cabinet has decided to form a dedicated high-level committee to negotiate the final tender rates and cap the financial viability gap before awarding the contract.
Just about this time, DK Shivakumar, the man behind the relentless push for what are clearly two VIP lanes crisscrossing the city, became the Chief Minister. It was clearly ironic that the national leadership of Congress, headed by Rahul Gandhi, had been very critical of billionaire businessman Gautam Adani, his proximity to the BJP and how he has slipped out of every corruption allegation.
At the same time, the Congress-ruled government in Karnataka was only too happy to accommodate Adani, even if his estimate of the total construction cost was more than 25%. The generous concessionaire agreement under the Build-Own-Operate-Transfer (BOOT) model had a 34-year concession period, which can be extended up to 44 years if toll revenue falls short. With all this, the state government was eventually constrained only by the High court order, which said that any contract awarded would be subject to the final outcome.
The other, of course, was the massive public opposition to amendment to the Parks Act, which is now as good as dead. The hope now is that the government is entangled in enough petitions that they might not proceed on the tunnel project.
“We knew it would definitely end up in court. What happens there is not in our control or in anybody's control. My point is the daringness of the government. It has never happened before. It has happened earlier in subtle ways, but this is the first time that the government is coming out and saying that we will do this; what can you do? And I blame 99.5% bureaucracy for it, not the political system. The political system is a beneficiary of this process. So we wanted to send a message too,” said Yellappa Reddy. And that message, he says, is a legitimate solution to traffic congestion.
Some of the activists are now hoping that the government will not revive the tunnel project immediately, especially after the backlash to the amendment that would have allowed them to take over 5% of parks and hand them over for commercial activities.
But so far, all DK Shivakumar has offered is to change the alignment so the tunnel roads avoid Lalbagh.
Minister Rizwan Arshad, who is the MLA from Shivajinagar, said that at least the government is providing a solution, and that was better than doing nothing at all. Speaking to TNM, he said, “We are not doing anything that is not being done across the globe, something that has been tried and tested across the globe and has been successful. And what about the environmental impact of the slow movement of traffic, with hundreds of vehicles waiting at junctions to clear signals and the kind of addition we are making to traffic every day with newer vehicles coming in? It is not something very small or negligible.
Stating that the government would not take up such a big project without proper studies, he said, “Bengaluru also has an issue where there are certain people who will not allow anything to happen. At the same time, they will complain that nothing is happening. For example, the Hebbal side of the bridge. Those people who opposed it could not give us a solution to it. And the party which opposed it was in power for five years, and they did not do anything about it.”
He dismissed political opposition to the project and said a few others had genuine concerns, and they would be addressed. “Bengaluru's history has been like that. You try to do something, and there will be a lot of opposition. Our past experiences show us that if you keep quiet, then nothing will move. So, we are aware of these challenges.
He also said that the government was not neglecting public transport. “We have a vision of taking the metro up to 500 kilometres. We have a mission for buses and suburban rail.
So also the tunnel, and there are certain elevated corridors. We might not be very intelligent people, but we want to bring certain projects in the interest of the city and for the future of this city. No one can stop Bengaluru from growing. The only thing is, how do you accommodate future growth?
At a ‘Meet with Editors’ in September, the CM Shivakumar made it clear. No matter the opposition, the project will continue. Was it worth the political risk of involving Adani and angering people on the other side, editors queried? “Many years from now, people will thank me for this project,” the CM declared.
This report was first published by The News Minute.
Also Read
-
In Mohan Yadav’s Ujjain, journalists critical of him ‘were targeted’ until they left
-
Palestinians killed, hospitals shelled: How Deutsche Bank arms Israel
-
Sonbhadra-Singrauli: The land that gives us light, and the people poisoned with its ash
-
Five years of reporting on the Yamuna: When you pay, the questions never stop
-
Amid rising attacks on Christians, Bengal BJP chief warns missionary schools; Bishop seeks CM intervention