Video

Five years of reporting on the Yamuna: When you pay, the questions never stop

Thick, toxic white foam has returned to long stretches of the Yamuna in Delhi. Women in Chhath finery stand waist-deep in it. Officials stand on the bank with spray pipes. The cameras arrive on schedule.

If this feels like a rerun, it is, and the money behind it isn't small potatoes. 

The Delhi government spent over Rs 6,000 crore between 2017 and 2022 on cleaning the Yamuna, according to the Centre for Science and Environment, and the results were far from satisfactory. This year, the Delhi government’s ‘Green Budget’ has earmarked Rs 6,485 crore for the river. How much more is being spent on advertising efforts, we don't know yet. What we do know is that sections of the media have hailed them without asking what the earlier crores achieved. Someone has to ask what these numbers have bought. 

We have been asking since 2021.  

[Small teams can do great things. All it takes is a subscription. Subscribe now and power Newslaundry’s work.]  

In November 2021, we stood at Kalindi Kunj as devotees performed Chhath amid a thick layer of foam, telling us their faith would protect them. Two months later, we walked the 22 km that the Yamuna travels through Delhi, from Wazirabad to Okhla. 

A prominent ecologist working with the Delhi government told us the river there is “ecologically dead”. Three Yamuna action plans and thousands of crores later, the results weren’t visible.

Cut to 2023. The river broke its 1978 record and flooded the city. We reported on the people the relief effort had missed. Days earlier, the government had announced about 200 camps for kanwariyas, with beds, coolers and the Chief Minister’s photographs. The food relief camps got no toilets, no clear instructions, and a school shelter with 20-25 beds for over 100 people.

Then we asked a question the political slugfest had no room for: was Haryana’s barrage water really the only culprit? Our reporter Anmol Pritam went to the floodplain and found otherwise. Permanent structures had come up on the river’s own space, and 2,480 hectares of the floodplain were encroached upon between 2009 and 2022. In the village we reached, residents told us no government aid had arrived.

Then came the years of looking at what the clean-up actually consisted of. In October 2024, with foam on the river again, Anmol traced it back to untreated sewage and concretisation. In January 2025, we used an RTI to examine the Lieutenant Governor’s role in the high-level committee meant to clean the river. Anmol found that he had attended only five of at least ten meetings. But it's not just about the river and the ecology it supports; it's also about the people who live in its vicinity. So, a month later, Anmol examined whether it was fair to evict farmers from the floodplain to build a park.

Last October, ahead of Chhath, the Delhi government declared the Yamuna clean enough for devotees. Anmol went to check and found open drains still discharging sewage and dead animals in the water. Three weeks after Chhath, the foam was back, with seven boats spraying chemicals and Delhi still releasing 641 million litres of untreated sewage into the river every day.

But the government wasn’t the only party whose claims needed checking. We also watched what the television media did with the story. The Chief Minister sat down with Doordarshan’s Sudhir Chaudhary and Aaj Tak’s Anjana Om Kashyap at Vasudev Ghat. Their backdrop was not the river but what the opposition alleged was a man-made pond filled with filtered water. We tried to reach the spot and were denied entry. On Times Now Navbharat, Sushant Sinha’s primetime monologue promised that the Prime Minister and Chief Minister would make everything pure again, without a word on the data.

That is the part of the story most newsrooms skip. A river doesn’t stay dirty only because officials look away. It stays dirty because those meant to hold them to account look away too.

This year, it’s the same story with bigger numbers. A Rs 91 lakh study on frothing. A Rs 6,485 crore allocation to the Jal Board. Tonnes of defoamer. And, as Khushi Mehrotra reported this week, foam that returns within an hour or so after spraying stops. The experts we spoke to say the chemical makes the foam disappear without making the water any cleaner. 

Anmol and Akankhya Rout’s report from the ground showed what lies behind the photo ops – clean water piped into artificial ghats, and politicians who pick their stretch of river with care. And days before Chhath, when a video of dead fish in the Yamuna set off a political row, Akankhya reported on Surendra Singh Azad, the BSP worker who posted it. He was arrested under an FIR that accuses unidentified persons of dumping fish to tarnish the government’s image. The cause of the fish deaths is still not established.

Every year the clean-up is announced before Chhath, and the foam arrives during it. The intervening period is filled with press releases and friendly interviews. What Newslaundry does is keep the receipts, and return long after the cameras leave.

That is what we do, and it is not cheap. A reporter at the river’s edge, a repeated visit to the same drain, an RTI that takes months, a data set read line by line. All this work takes time and money, and it doesn’t get funded by those who benefit from the foam being forgotten. Newslaundry exists because readers like you pay for it.

Your subscription pays for the next trip to the banks of the Yamuna, the next RTI, and the next time someone, in public office or on primetime, has to answer for the gap between the claim and the water. The government has a PR budget and an entire media industry dedicated to trumpeting its claims. We have you.

Help us document what is happening to our environment – and hold those responsible to account. You can support Project Vande Mataram here. 

Also Read: Who is Surendra Singh Azad, the man booked over a video of dead fish in the Yamuna?

Also Read: Lakhs spent on removing the foam on Yamuna. Here’s why that won’t clean the river

Also Read: Delhi govt’s ‘clean Yamuna’ PR stunt exposed: Fake ghats, photo ops, filthy water