Shot

‘Why is India moving backwards?’ John Abraham seeks withdrawal of animal experimentation draft rules

Actor John Abraham has written to the Centre asking it to withdraw the draft rules on animal experimentation, breeding and trade.

In an October 22 letter to the Ministry of Animal Husbandry, the Bollywood actor expressed his strong opposition to the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (Control and Supervision of Experiments, Breeding and Trading of Animals) Draft Rules. 

“We are living in an age of artificial intelligence, organ-on-chip technology, advanced cell-based research and computational models capable of investigating biological processes and predicting certain human responses,” he wrote. He conceded the limits of these methods, which “may not yet replace every form of animal research,” but argued that their “rapid development makes it imperative that India invest in and accelerate this transition rather than weaken the safeguards that govern animal experimentation.”

The question at the heart of his letter was blunt: “Why is India moving backwards when science is creating new possibilities for a more humane and potentially more human-relevant approach to research?”

Abraham spoke of animals “subjected to invasive procedures, infection, injury, pain and distress in the name of scientific progress.” He added: “They DO NOT consent to these experiments. They cannot ask whether an alternative existed, whether the experiment was necessary, or whether the benefits justified their suffering.”

John Abraham's letter

Critics of these draft rules like animal rights activist Ambika Shukla have argued that they weaken safeguards built over decades. “Poorly regulated experiments produce unreliable data. Unreliable data leads to flawed science. And flawed science can ultimately put human lives at risk,” she wrote for Newslaundry.

She objected to animals bred for research being replaced by animals “obtained from virtually any source”, and asked how researchers could establish their health status. The draft allows livestock, farm animals, fish and birds to be sourced from non-registered establishments or the open market when registered suppliers lack them, subject to institutional approval and quarantine. Stray and feral animals remain barred except under narrow exemptions. Shukla also objected to a definition of “establishment” that includes mobile facilities, which the draft does not otherwise elaborate on.

On oversight, Shukla argued that “internal oversight has a role, but it cannot become a substitute for independent regulation.” 

Under the draft, mild and moderate experiments will be cleared by an institution’s ethics committee without referral to the Committee for Control and Supervision of Experiments on Animals (CCSEA), the statutory regulator for animal research. These committees include four CCSEA-nominated members, and the regulator retains approval of severe and non-recovery experiments on animals larger than rodents and rabbits.

Critics have also questioned the consultation process. After the 30-day feedback period ended on November 5, a further notification sought comments only from medical colleges registered with the National Medical Commission.

Furthermore, Abraham’s letter also argued that weaker rules could hurt human health. 

“Scientific progress cannot be measured by the number of animals subjected to experiments, nor can public health be protected by compromising scientific rigour,” Abraham wrote. “Poorly designed or insufficiently predictive testing can create a false sense of security. Our pursuit of cheaper or more convenient pathways must never come at the cost of reliable science, safe medicines or public trust.”

He framed the dispute as a choice between “advancing science responsibly” and “retaining practices that increasingly demand ethical and scientific scrutiny.”

Any replacement framework to these draft rules, he said, “must strengthen transparency, accountability, independent oversight and animal welfare,” and “must also actively encourage the development, validation and adoption of scientifically sound alternatives to animal testing,” while also asking the government to “initiate a transparent, consultative process”. 

Animals can’t comment on draft rules or read the fine print. That job falls to the rest of us, and it needs journalism that stays with a story after the first headline. Support our work here.

On a lighter note, Newslaundry now has an office cat, and she has no name. For Rs 99, you get two weeks of Newslaundry and a chance to name her.

Also Read: A licence to kill: Why India’s new rules put science and lives at risk