Books
A private odyssey: Belonging, without reckoning
Last summer, along Lake Como, close to the place where Benito Mussolini was captured and killed by the Resistance Group, I came across his framed photographs being sold publicly. Unlike Germans, many Italians have not had a sustained reckoning with their Fascist past, often deluding themselves into believing it to be an aberration.
The summer spent in Italy returned to me while reading Congress leader Sonia Gandhi’s memoir Belonging: A Journey of Love. She records in vivid detail the kindness and generosity of her father Stefano Maino, who had served in the Italian army under the Fascist government. “Not for nothing was he known to his comrades as Maino il Leone – Maino the Lion – as much loved by his men as he was feared,” she writes.
The daughterly love is understandable, but here’s a leader who acutely records the threats of right-wing politics in the country she adopted, but is reluctant to confront the one she was born in. The memoir is silent about any possible shadow of Mussolini’s military campaigns over Maino’s life.
Saviour complex
The autobiography is a genre in omission. It doesn’t carry the whole truth about the author. It’s a story of what they chose to reveal, what they want the world to know about themselves. Even the most truthful man of the last century, who penned one of the most candid autobiographies, managed to conceal from its pages a love affair he found himself consumed by in the thirteenth year of his vow of celibacy. A relationship which, in the words of his conscience keeper C Rajagopalachari, could bring him “unspeakable shame and death”; a bond that, wrote his future biographer Ramachandra Guha, “came very close” to being “consummated sexually”.
The genre, thus, is an exercise in self-deception too. The narrator does not merely conceal a truth from the public gaze; the greater desire is to hide it from themselves.
For Belonging, the moment arrives early in the book. Indira Gandhi, in her daughter-in-law’s version, decided to carve a major role for herself in politics because “she had begun to feel that the party to which her father had given his life was moving away from its socialist and secular ideals”. These are telling words. The Congress party was built and nourished by numerous leaders; Sonia’s retelling only names Indira’s father. We thus learn that the consolidation of Indira’s control over the party wasn’t driven by a ruthless ambition. Indira is projected as a selfless woman pushed into politics to save the party.
She describes Indira’s brief incarceration in Tihar jail during the Janata Party government with profound empathy. “I was moved to tears seeing her tiny figure sitting on a metal chair in the corner of that bare, cold jail cell.”
The passage is striking for what it chooses to leave out – citizens jailed and victimised by Indira’s government during the Emergency.
Sonia not only absolves Indira Gandhi; even Sanjay Gandhi, whom the book seeks to hold responsible, is allowed only a mild blame. In fact, in the very paragraph she lends him “a significant role in decision-making during the Emergency”, Sonia adds: “Whatever his faults may have been, Sanjay was no coward… he had enough courage in him to face any situation and to fight his way back to political leadership.”
The nation must be grateful to Sanjay for his bravery.
Belonging seems to rest on a belief that the author’s family is the sole saviour of the party and the nation, carrying the singular burden to redeem them. Even sympathetic reviewers have expressed discomfort about the prism through which the book looks at Indian politics. The prejudice runs deep. The book refuses to confront the difficult political inheritance of the author, and then goes on to construct an alternative, morally flattering account about the family.
Furthering a dynasty’s agenda
There’s a book that’s read for its prose, for its insights, for its wisdom. There’s another that carries an immediate news value. Great books refuse to yield to the immediate. Whether Belonging will truly belong, endure beyond its immediate news cycle, is another question.
It is not without its merits. It brings to the world the personal story of a woman who had faced cruel and cynical attacks for decades, a woman who maintained rare composure through the difficult years of her public life. By now, there’s a general consensus that the book can be neatly divided into two sections: the personal and the political. While the personal is often moving and riveting, the political is mostly inauthentic.
Belonging does humanise the author. She courageously brings romance and love into public discourse. It rests on an enchanting affair between an Italian girl and an Indian boy in England, a relationship that deeply impacted the course of independent India. Then there’s a relationship between Indira and Feroze Gandhi, with more than a few glimpses of the complexities that had crept between them.
Had this book remained solely a personal memoir, it would be more humane and evocative. As it delves into politics, a territory the book is not prepared for, it increasingly comes across as a vehicle to further the dynasty’s agenda.
It also begets an unsettling question: can there be any authenticity to the personal if the public is flawed? Can one trust the personal, if the author refuses to examine the political inheritance that has shaped her own private identity? Can a work that doesn’t examine the public self of its author be trusted with the description of their private life? What if the personal recollection, too, is a vehicle to reinforce the public image?
One can concede that an emotionally revealing work may be intellectually evasive; the two traits may coexist without erasing the other.
The kernel truth, then, of an autobiography is the spirit of self-enquiry. A spirit that elevates the genre despite its omissions, and lends it an intellectual and moral worth.
George Orwell’s Shooting an Elephant penetratingly dissects the dilemma and the consequent burden of privilege. He doesn’t spare himself as he goes on to interrogate his position of authority and the uncomfortable mask he is forced to carry to sustain the privilege.
Belonging need not have distanced itself from Stefano Maino. Nor did Sonia Gandhi need to apologise for the excesses of her mother-in-law. But she was certainly expected to scrutinise the political choices of her mother-in-law, her husband and her son. A memoir that undertakes to project her family as saviours of a beleaguered nation could have acknowledged their own complicity in nourishing a political culture that favours the entitled and damages the foundations of democracy. Except for the mild criticism of Sanjay Gandhi during the Emergency, the memoir barely displays a consciousness that the family could have done any wrong. The memoir overlooks what numerous citizens of the country believe: the family is a part of the problem the nation is suffering from – and not all of them are right-wingers.
Belonging begins as an evocative recollection of a young Italian girl falling in love and then, as a bride, finding her feet in a foreign country. By the end it becomes an attempt to shield the dynasty from the inconvenient demands of truth. An autobiography that refuses self-examination becomes an exercise in self-affirmation.
Ashutosh Bhardwaj is an independent writer and journalist.
On a lighter note, Newslaundry now has an office cat, and she has no name. For Rs 99, you get two weeks of Newslaundry and a chance to name her.
Also Read
-
Bulldozers, chainsaws and ‘parkification’: What’s happening to Delhi’s Central Ridge
-
The price of Delhi’s deshbhakti: Giant flags to be replaced every month, a bigger bill with new tender
-
Sonbhadra-Singrauli: The land that gives us light, and the people poisoned with its ash
-
In Mohan Yadav’s Ujjain, journalists critical of him ‘were targeted’ until they left
-
एनएल चर्चा 450: न्याय की लंबी लड़ाई में बिलक़ीस बानो की नई चुनौती और मैदान से धोनी की विदाई