National anthem insulted? How a year-old story resurfaces for everyone to outrage and write columns

We in the news media should always get the other side of the story, as this case suggests.

01 (1)

On January 3, The New Indian Express carried a story about a teacher in a Kolkata Madrassa “being viciously assaulted by maulanas and their henchmen, for training students to sing the national anthem for the Republic Day”. The reporter’s sources apparently also told him that “many of the radical Muslim clerics who attacked Akhtar are rooting for the ISIS”.

Soon, other media houses like Zee News, NewsX and Catch News followed suit. All the reports were similar and based on the solitary version of the teacher, Kazi Masum Akhtar.

The Huffington Post even carried a column on it by Sandip Roy, asking the media to ensure the “case is not just a local news footnote”. “Hopefully the media will also stand up for him,” Roy wrote.

Soon, Twitter’s outrage brigade jumped on the story and a hashtag was born: #NationalAnthemInsulted.

jaggi kanchan gupta

This article is made possible because of Newslaundry's subscribers.Click here and Pay To Keep News Free

Roy is right. If a schoolteacher was beaten up for teaching his students the national anthem of the country, it definitely warrants more coverage. But since most stories have two sides to them, we figured we’d seek out the other version too.

In that bid, we spoke to the current teacher-in-charge of the school, Ferdousi Begum. Begum, who is a School Service Commission examination qualified teacher and has been teaching in the Madrassa since 2012, has a version significantly different from Akhtar’s. According to Begum, Akhtar had run into trouble with certain conservative parents last year because of his outspoken nature. “He was extremely critical of Islamic traditions and that irked a few parents as most of our students come from quite disadvantaged socio-economic backgrounds,” she explained.

On March 26, 2015, Begum said, Akhtar had a run-in with some parents, when they barged inside the school compound, holding him hostage. “However, the police was called in soon, and other teachers shielded him.” Begum admitted that while the police was escorting Akhtar out of the Madrassa gate, he did get roughed up and his head was injured in the process.

Was the parents’ ire a result of Akhtar teaching the kids to sing the national anthem? “Not at all, the national anthem has always been sung in the school – and it continues to be done so. You can come, check any time you want to and even ask the students.”

Also, did anything happen recently that led to the media reports? “He hasn’t stepped foot inside the school since that day, so I don’t understand how he could be beaten up for training students to sing the national anthem on Republic Day.”

Another teacher in the Madrasa, Sudipto Kumar Mondal, who has been with the school since 2005, echoed Begum’s claims. “The national anthem features in the school diary. It has been a practice to sing the national anthem in the morning assembly much before Akhtar joined,” he said

20160107022246(1)

Akhtar’s version of events, as recounted by him over a phone call, predictably differs from his colleagues’. Curiously though, his version doesn’t even reiterate the various news reports on the matter. He said he wasn’t beaten up recently (as news reports seem to suggest quite explicitly); he maintained the only time he was beaten up was on March 26, 2015. “I was persecuted because I hold liberal views and tried to reform many wrong practices like child marriage. He claimed his co-teachers are conspiring against him because he was a hard taskmaster and “disciplined” them. “I wanted to make the Madrassa like any other school – and fundamentalists with vested interests have targeted me for that.”

But what about his colleagues’ claims that the national anthem has always been sung in the school? “That’s not true, I started this nationalistic tradition,” he maintained. Also, does he believe it was his insistence on students singing the national anthem that led to him being attacked? “It was one of the many things.”

He insisted that the attack on him in March last year was pre-mediated and was a result of him challenging status quo. “They wanted me to grow my beard and wear a skull cap.”

Shirajul Islam Mondal, member of the Madrasa’s managing committee, rubbishes Akhtar’s assertions. “There are about seven Hindu teachers in the Madrassa. No one has ever claimed such a thing. This is completely false.” What about the national anthem? “We are Bharatiyas – why would anyone have a problem with the national anthem?”

In this story – essentially Akhtar’s word against his colleagues’ and employers’ – there are some facts that are not contestable: Akhtar was roughed up in March last year; he has not stepped inside the Madrasa since then and so the question of him training students to sing the national anthem this Republic Day doesn’t arise.

Why then did The New Indian Express make its story sound so? The story does not mention the year, leading readers to believe Akhtar was roughed up now. What made the journalist report almost a year-old story all of sudden when there were no new developments? When contacted, the reporter of the story declined to comment. When we enquired with Akhtar, he said the reporter had gotten in touch with him. Did he know the reporter? “Yes, he is an acquaintance.”

Even more peculiarly, none of the other news organisations, which followed up on The New Indian Express’ story, bothered to get a reaction from the other side. Roy, one of the country’s most readable journalists, wrote a full column, basing it on glaringly one-sided news reports, in the process giving the story much oxygen and credence.

This is not the first time an opinion columnist has written a column too soon. Last year, Rana Ayyub wrote an opinion piece in DailyO, linking the rape of a nun in West Bengal to the RSS, barely days after the incident, when hardly any facts had emerged. The police, soon after, arrested four Bangladeshi men for the crime.

Quick response-to-news pieces in the digital era are inevitable. But basing them on reports that at least attempt to be fair would still not be a bad idea. It would save not just the reader’s time, but also the writer’s.

NL Subscription Banner

All our articles are run through a software to avoid the possibility of unattributed work finding its way into Newslaundry.

1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (105 votes, average: 3.96 out of 5)
Loading...

 

More from Arunabh Saikia


Contribute Your Views
  • disqus_7fHdRBOXBt

    something on malda too, sakia?

    • DJ Snake

      Absolutely! पुच्चीबरोबर लवड़ा पाहिजेच पाहिजे.

  • Guru Nekkare

    But IE is known for that. Wasn’t the “coup” story by Shekhar Gupta months after the incident? So what’s new?

    • SRG

      This is New IE from the south, not Coupta’s IE.

    • apu589

      The New Indian Express is different. It’s editor is Prabhu Chawla. NIE rarely gives false or inciting news unlike its stupid brother-the Indian Express

  • SRG

    I see NIE article mentions he was attacked in March and was in hospital for months, why do you say it hides the fact that the incident happened recently?

  • Ronnie

    Just love the righteous indignation from bleeding heart leftist loonies, crazy for Facebook likes.
    – Muslims are the real victim
    – isolated act of one / few

    – they were provoked
    – Hindus need to be more tolerant
    – Not singing National anthem is “personal choice”
    Time to treat the fifth columnists as traitors.

  • apu589

    Stupid article. What are the chances that Madrasa teachers are not lying? In fact I saw a Madarasa educated man not stand up during the National Anthem in a coaching institute. Upon asking the reason he said it’s non-Islamic. So your entire article is another one-sided story!

    • Internet Guardian

      You mean just like the bigots of RSS who refused to accept the Naational Flag till 2002?

      • apu589

        First rule: Don’t believe everything shown in mainstream media without scrutinizing it.

        Second Rule: If you don’t have a counter argument, don’t drag a third party to make your point.

  • Pussylibs

    Hmm..get the other aide of story on 548 people murder by secars in Bihar.
    Malda riots, oh you guys are too pussy to fight islamists, I’ll make my do Jesuit charlie but won’t take chance myself..

    Nothing manly libtarda preaching tolerance to comparatively llmore tolerant hindus try something on Mullahs.

    BTW, mulla threatened one of your journos to behed, where is your drama Queen madhu, I will fight for journos, we are strong,a we are one? Saale aap log bhi troll hi ho, kagazi sher, like Kejru..tattoo log..

  • Pooja Solanki

    “Get the other side”

    you mean we give platform to extremist to express how beating up a teacher for either teaching national anthem (according to him) or being critical of islam (according to teachers in this article) is justifiable ?

  • P. B. Josh

    The main reason is, WB has become an Iron curtain region. It is made that way by our leftist Presstitute media. Most people did not know about this incident for almost an year.

  • Subodh

    A man was beaten up with iron rods in March last year for being critical of Islamic traditions,

    But media ignored the story because “growing intolerance” was not in fashion and because the intolerant community was not Hindu.

    9 month later, the story finally surfaces..

    But Saikia instead of questioning why the story was ignored for so many months gets outraged over the fact that New Indian Express picked the story late.. *smh*

    The crux of the matter is that stories of Muslim intolerance are routinely ignored or downplayed by our media while every crime against a Muslim, minor or major, is elevated to the rank of a national tragedy and fingers are pointed towards forces of Hindutva.

  • lifesorchestra

    Because of such one sided news reporting (as correctly mentioned in above article) and reporting being based on prejudices and biases, people are losing trust in reporters. The news reporting community is lowering the niveau at an exponential rate. Twitter does not help either rather take arguments to ridiculous levels 😐

  • Abhinav

    Sad that yet again Hindutva reactionaries spread bullshit like this. Thanks Newslaundry for bringing the whole story.

  • Infinite Wisdom

    The author seems like a Marxist fiberal Congi award wapasi type. He never reported on the incident as Marxist fiberal Congi ward wapasi type only see things through a communal prism of how to find fault with Hindus and how to ignore any issues with Muslims. This joker has gone one step beyond and now that somebody else has reported the incident, he is doing his best to discredit the report.

  • Pijush

    good job saikia..yes adding the moulavi’s side might get u a 5star

  • mahak

    Sad that yet again IsLamic Reactionaries does bullshit like this. Thanks Commentators on this article for bringing the unanswered issues again into the light

    Menu