Hindi vs Kannada: A battle for identity
What needs to be recognised is that Kannada, like any other regional language, is not a mere medium of communication. It is an emotion.
In July 2017, several stations of Bengaluru Metro Rail came under attack, almost simultaneously. Kannada activists, mostly representing Karnataka Rakshana Vedika, sprayed black paint on the Hindi signage at the stations while shouting slogans against the imposition of Hindi. Soon after, the Metro authorities decided to be safe than sorry — restricting the names of the stations to English and Kannada.
Support Independent Media
The media must be free and fair, uninfluenced by corporate or state interests. That's why you, the public, need to pay to keep news free.
ContributeUsually, such protests would be dismissed as an act of parochial Kannada organisations who do not have a larger worldview. They also tend to be taken over by rowdy elements, who use muscle power to get their point across. But this protest was unique. Its supporter base also included software professionals who were concerned about the Kannada language not being given its place of pride.
Vasant Shetty and Vallish call themselves linguists. Their day jobs see them at a tech firm and a start-up respectively. What binds them together is the feeling of angst that Kannada is being pushed to play second fiddle to Hindi, even in Karnataka. Their argument is that Hindi cannot be the link language for Kannadigas.
The problem with a one-size-fits-all approach is that if there is a perception that homogeneity is being shoved down the throat, it will be opposed fiercely. What needs to be recognised is that Kannada, like any other regional language, is not a mere medium of communication. It is an emotion.
The alternate view, however, is that turning states into islands of regionalism is not healthy for the concept of India as a nation. There is also a risk in taking the Kannada-language issue too far because if it is perceived as an anti-Hindi pitch, it undermines the contribution of an outsider to Bengaluru and Karnataka’s development. Political analyst Sugata Raju points out that today 60 per cent of Karnataka’s revenue comes from Bengaluru.
“This is the engine that is running a very backward area like north Karnataka. If you start accentuating the debate then there may be divisions within the state which you may not be able to handle politically,” says Sugata Raju. But what would worry the BJP this election season is the perception of the party being cow-belt focused, for this reason, the anti-Hindi sentiment and anti-BJPism tend to overlap.
Language has become an important issue in this election because of the manner in which the Congress has played the regional identity card, giving the BJP a taste of its own medicine.
Hindi vs Kannada, as the language issue has, unfortunately, been positioned, also reflects itself in the north vs south divide over the allocation of funds. After Amit Shah alleged that central funds given by the NDA regime were being gobbled up by a “corrupt” Congress government, Siddaramaiah hit back by pointing out that for every rupee that Karnataka gives to the Centre by way of taxes, it gets only 47 paise in return. The point being made is that Karnataka is subsidising the bimaru states while struggling for funds to develop its own backward areas.
Which is why I see this Karnataka election as a test for the people of the state. Their choice will be their commentary on their identity, their pride and what they approve of and what they detest. And hopefully, there will be important learning for everyone involved.
Power NL-TNM Election Fund
General elections are around the corner, and Newslaundry and The News Minute have ambitious plans together to focus on the issues that really matter to the voter. From political funding to battleground states, media coverage to 10 years of Modi, choose a project you would like to support and power our journalism.
Ground reportage is central to public interest journalism. Only readers like you can make it possible. Will you?