Anti-SIR protest: Journalists’ accounts differ from Delhi Police’s affidavit to Supreme Court

Newslaundry compared the police affidavit with the accounts of the journalists it names, and found gaps regarding detention, release and seized equipment.

WrittenBy:Khushi Mehrotra& Akankhya Rout
Date:
Article image

In an affidavit to the Supreme Court, the Delhi Police has defended its handling of journalists during the anti-SIR protests by claiming that any journalists caught up in police action were either mistakenly identified as protesters or removed as part of crowd-control measures. It also claimed that journalists were released as soon as their professional credentials were verified.

But journalists’ accounts tell a different story.

Newslaundry compared the affidavit, filed in response to petitions by the Network of Women in Media, Free Speech Collective, Delhi Union of Journalists and the Kerala Union of Working Journalists, with the accounts of several journalists. The accounts diverge on several points.

Journalists say they were not released after an ID check but only after a senior officer phoned or when a vehicle broke down. While police claim The Caravan’s Ryan Thomas was never detained and termed the claim that his equipment was seized as “false”, Thomas says he was put in a bus and there is a medico-legal report confirming assault. While journalists point to seized, damaged or missing gear, the police deny the allegation.

Silence on Caravan journalist being assaulted

Delhi Police maintained that Ryan Thomas, a journalist with The Caravan, was neither detained nor kept at any holding facility during the October 11 protest. The affidavit said, “He was merely removed from the site in exercise of the statutory powers vested in the police authorities, in the course of the ongoing crowd protest.”

The police neither denied nor accepted Thomas’s allegation that he was assaulted. The affidavit stated, “It is submitted that in so far as the medico-legal case is concerned, the matter is presently under investigation. I am, therefore, advised not to disclose any further details in this regard at this stage in the present affidavit.”

Thomas told Newslaundry, “I was holding my press card up. However, I was put in a detention bus, where I was beaten first. Then, they tried to take away my equipment, however, I put it in my bag. Then, later they took me to a jeep and beat me there.”

Thomas also claimed that the police threatened to put him in a bus but eventually let him go. He said the alleged assault lasted less than half an hour and took place in Connaught Place.

Thomas obtained a medico-legal certificate (MLC) at Ram Manohar Lohia Hospital, where he told the hospital staff that police personnel had beaten him while he was reporting on the protests. According to a report by The Caravan, doctors examined him and ordered tests, including a CT scan.

The MLC did not mention that the injury had allegedly been caused by the police.

Thomas told Newslaundry that two Delhi Police officials visited his residence on October 25 to verify some details. “The police insisted that I was not put in a detention centre, which I agreed to. However, I told them that I was kept in a police vehicle against my will.”

Thomas clarified that he had not filed an FIR. However, he was part of a contempt petition filed along with other journalists in the matter and said he would now be sending a legal notice to Delhi Police.

‘Immediately released’ or held for hours

In its affidavit, Delhi Police said there was no “mala fide” intent in its actions against journalists. “Some journalists were mistakenly identified as protestors in the absence of conspicuously displayed identification/accreditation. However, the moment the journalistic credentials of any person were ascertained, such a person was immediately released.” 

Newslaundry spoke to Scroll’s Ayush Tiwari, who was detained on October 10. “My detention happened near HKS Surjeet Bhawan. I was standing outside, wearing my press card and recording the action, when they pulled me. I shouted that I was a journalist, and showed them my ID.”

Tiwari said he was detained at 11 am and remained in custody for an hour and a half. “The bus I was in caught fire near Paharganj police station and that’s when I was able to go,” he said.

Tiwari added that the other detainees were taken inside the police station and that police personnel kept asking him to come inside. He refused and left. 

Three Newslaundry reporters – Astha Savyasachi, Ashwine Singh and Anmol Pritam – along with Anshu Anand, an intern with Newslaundry, were also detained by Delhi Police.

Singh said, “Around 11:30 am on October 10, our colleague Anmol Pritam was detained by the Delhi Police. He was going towards the New Delhi Railway Station.” 

In the process, Astha and Ashwine were also detained. “I showed them my card. I used to work with NDTV until two months ago and I still had my PIB card which is valid till December. I had a photo of the card on my personal phone.” Singh said this happened between 11:30 am and noon. 

Newslaundry reporters were released after a senior Delhi Police officer called and informed the police personnel concerned about their identity. This entire incident lasted approximately three to four hours

The Quint’s reporter, Sarthak, was detained outside Samrat Chowk and taken to Chanakyapuri Police Station. In a report, Sarthak described the verification process: “They checked our press ID cards and said this is not a PIB card. They told us ‘We don’t know your organisation so we need to do some verification, anyone is now roaming with fake IDs’.”

“They kept us waiting there. We did not know if we were detained because we were told that it was a verification. They will check our documents and call our employer and we will be let go. However, this entire incident lasted for 4-5 hours.”

Obstruction of duty?

On October 11, the Supreme Court, while hearing a PIL filed by several advocates, said that “journalists and other professionals shall not be hindered in discharge of their professional duties in any manner whatsoever”.

However, journalists said the police continued to detain media persons during the protests. At least 10 journalists were detained from different parts of the New Delhi and Central Delhi districts. The police affidavit specifically addresses the removal of media persons near RK Ashram Marg. Around seven to eight journalists were detained and later dropped off.

Delhi Police said its personnel at RK Ashram Marg were being obstructed by the crowd while carrying out their duties. Those obstructing them were removed for verification, and some journalists were inadvertently caught up in the crowd and taken along. The police said they were released as soon as their professional identities were established. The affidavit cites a video recorded by senior journalist Sreenivasan Jain. In it, a senior police officer says personnel were unaware that the woman taken into the police vehicle was a journalist. After being informed of her identity, the officer directed that she be released.

However, the journalists’ accounts describe getting out of buses by other means, not with a simple verification.

Hindustan Times reporter Ashish Singh, 27, was detained from R.K. Ashram Marg around 2:30 pm. He was pushed around and injured despite wearing an ID card that clearly identified him as a member of the press, according to a report by Hindustan Times. “I told them not once but many times that I’m a HT reporter and I was also wearing my ID card, which I showed them. But they didn’t listen to me,” he said.

Singh was on the bus for around 20-30 minutes. When it reached the Mandir Marg area, he and the other journalist jumped out of the bus.

Newslaundry also spoke to two reporters from Kerala – Sajin Kairali of AsiaNet News and Suhail Muhammad of 24 News – who were also detained.

“When I spotted a police personnel dragging a protester on the road, I told him that the person was getting hurt. Later, I was detained along with my cameraperson. They were taking us in rounds and eventually after approximately 30 minutes, the bus stopped in Connaught Place and we were able to leave,” Suhail said.

Kairali said he spotted a fellow Malayali journalist being detained. “I think the bus was running out of fuel. Additionally, there was intervention by some journalists from 24 News who started raising questions about the detentions,” he claimed.

In another video report recorded by Jain on October 11, he is seen asking police personnel why journalists were being picked up despite the Supreme Court's order. No protesting crowd or demonstration is visible in the video. At least two police personnel can be heard telling Jain to maintain his distance, despite no protest being underway. The personnel can also be heard telling him, “Aaram se baat karo” – “Talk calmly”.

Can cops deny seizing journalists’ equipment?

In the affidavit, Delhi Police said: “It has been falsely contended by the petitioners that the police arbitrarily seized media equipment from journalists during the protest.”

However, two independent journalists from Punjab, Rajwinder and Lakhwinder Singh, who run the channel The Mike Report, said their camera was seized by the police while they were covering the protest.

Lakhwinder earlier said, “A senior police officer took the camera from me and gave it to a constable. We were released from detention around 8 pm.”

Rajwinder Singh said that it took them at least three to four days to find their camera. “They kept asking us to go from here to there. After there was pressure on social media and support of other journalists in Delhi, our camera was returned. Our equipment is safe,” he said.

The journalists said they were not given any seizure memo or other document for the equipment.

Equipment belonging to video journalist Vinay Gupta of No Noise Stories was taken away temporarily but was damaged. In a report by The News Minute from October 12, Gupta recounted what happened on October 10.

“I identified myself as a journalist and showed them my ID, but they still took my camera. I spent around half an hour requesting them to return it. When they finally did, the lens was broken, and the battery and memory card were missing. The police then took me to Jafarabad police station. There, they took my camera away again, saying that since I was being detained, I could not be allowed to keep it with me. I was released around 7:30 pm.” 

When Newslaundry reporter Anmol Pritam was being detained, the police first tried to snatch his microphone and later attempted to take his mobile phone.

Women journalists’ complaints

On the complaints by four women journalists, the police said the inquiry had been concluded for lack of corroboration. One complainant has gone to court and the next hearing is next month. Newslaundry spoke to three complainants including two mediapersons, one of whom is associated with a digital portal, and a third, who is also a social activist.

One of the complainants, the journalist associated with a digital portal, alleged in her complaint that she was sexually assaulted by ACP Vivek Bhagat near Kerala House while reporting. “I attended all the meetings with the police related to the investigation,” she told Newslaundry after the police affidavit.

Her lawyer, Advocate Saimon, said, “The police did not find sufficient evidence to register an FIR. They have sent a letter to the DCP and in the sexual harassment case, they approached the Magistrate, while in the SC/ST case, they moved the High Court seeking to quash the case. The next hearing is scheduled for December 1.”

Another complainant, an independent journalist who was also covering the protest, said in her complaint that she felt someone standing close to her. When she turned around, she saw a male police officer. She confronted him, but he dismissed her concerns. She said, “I asked the police not to register an FIR but to investigate the incident and identify the person involved.”

The third complainant is a social activist who also alleged that she was sexually assaulted by a police officer. She later told the police that she had family issues and did not want to get involved in a police case, and therefore did not wish to pursue the complaint further. She told Newslaundry, “I was at Ashoka Road on October 3. I was hit from behind. I am not sure whether it was his elbow or something else. When I turned around, I saw that it was a male police officer. I then called out to him, ‘Aapko sharam nahi aa rahi hai?’ The police officer then pushed me. I informed the CJP about the incident and filed a complaint. I got the receiving letter late at night.”

In her complaint, she mentioned that the police officer was not wearing a nameplate, but that she could identify him by his face.

Newslaundry has reached out to the Delhi Police’s PRO and New Delhi DCP for their response. This report will be updated once a response is received. 

Complaining about the media is easy. Why not do something to make it better? Support independent media and subscribe to Newslaundry today. 

Also see
article image‘A journalist would never shout slogans’: Delhi Police denies obstructing media at anti-CEC protest
article imageNearly 30 journalists recount the Delhi Police’s use of brute force against them

Comments

We take comments from subscribers only!  Subscribe now to post comments! 
Already a subscriber?  Login


You may also like